Manchester United will hope the appointment of Michael Carrick until the end of the season will bring subtle but important changes rather than wholesale upheaval, with clarity and balance likely to be prioritised over experimentation.
Carrick’s return to the dugout represents a familiar face stepping into a high-pressure environment, but one with a clear understanding of the squad and its strengths.
The 44-year-old has previously spoken about control, structure and responsibility in possession, and those principles are expected to shape his short-term approach in the Old Trafford dugout.
With little time to implement complex ideas ahead of a Manchester derby and a demanding fixture list ahead, selection choices will be as much about stability as tactical intent.
GIVEMESPORT has predicted Carrick’s best XI right now to steady United while retaining enough attacking threat to compete at the top level.
Lisandro Martinez Starts in Four-Man Defence
Carrick is expected to set United up in a 4-2-3-1 system focused on midfield control and positional discipline.
In goal, Senne Lammens will have a big responsibility, with United looking for composure and distribution from the back rather than constant shot-stopping heroics.
At right-back, Noussair Mazraoui offers tactical intelligence and comfort stepping into midfield, while Lisandro Martínez and Matthijs de Ligt form a physically strong yet ball-secure partnership centrally.
On the left, Luke Shaw provides experience and balance, capable of supporting attacks without leaving United exposed.
Kobbie Mainoo Continues Man United Revival
In midfield, Carrick is likely to lean heavily on Kobbie Mainoo alongside Bruno Fernandes with £70m man Casemiro cast aside.
Mainoo’s calmness under pressure and positional awareness suit Carrick’s preference for control, while Fernandes’ creativity and leadership remain central to United’s attacking output.
Ahead of them, Bryan Mbeumo is expected to operate from the right, offering direct running and work rate, with Mason Mount deployed centrally as a connector between midfield and attack. On the left, Matheus Cunha provides versatility, able to drift inside and link play rather than hugging the touchline.
Leading the line, Benjamin Sesko gives United a physical focal point, allowing attacks to be built with greater structure and offering a consistent target in the box.
What Carrick’s XI tells us about his approach
This predicted selection points towards pragmatism rather than revolution.
Carrick is likely to prioritise compactness, clear roles and midfield stability, trusting technical players to make decisions rather than overloading the system with instructions. The emphasis on ball-playing defenders and a composed double pivot reflects his belief in controlling games through possession rather than chaos.
In the short term, this XI would be about restoring coherence and confidence. Carrick’s task would not be to reinvent United, but to simplify, steady and give the squad a platform to perform while longer-term decisions are made.
Man Utd Star Could Leave in January Following Talks With Michael Carrick
Tyrell Malacia is facing decisive talks that could make him the first Carrick-era exit.
About Author
